A Cape Town man has lost his court bid to force a buyer to pay R3 million for a vintage 1965 Mercedes-Benz 600, IOL reported.
The Western Cape High Court found that the car was not delivered in the same condition it was in when the buyer first inspected it.
Acting Judge TJ Mgengwana dismissed the application by seller Geoffrey Leighton Ashmead. He wanted the court to declare the sale to Herman-Bosman Brand valid and binding.
Ashmead also asked the court to order Brand to pay the R3 million price, plus interest at 11.25% from 29 May 2025. The court ordered Ashmead to pay the costs.
The dispute began in October 2024. Ashmead asked car dealer Dean Knoep to sell the car for R3.5 million.
Knoep introduced Brand as a possible buyer. After inspecting and test-driving the car, Brand offered R3 million.
The two men signed a written sale agreement on 22 April 2025. It said the car was sold without warranties and in the condition in which it was first inspected.
The agreement also required Ashmead to deliver the car in that same condition. He also had to arrange a mechanical report from Central Garage, which had serviced the car for years.
Brand inspected the car again in May 2025. He said the front air vent under the windscreen would not close and oil was leaking underneath.
He said the windows would not open or close, and the boot lid would not shut properly. The car was also sitting unusually low, which pointed to a suspension problem.
Brand said these faults showed problems with the hydraulic, pneumatic and air suspension systems. These systems are among the features that give the car its value to collectors.
The car went back to Central Garage for repairs and was returned to Brand on 28 May. When he checked it the next day, he said the same faults were still there.
Brand then cancelled the deal. He said Ashmead had broken the contract by not delivering the car in its original condition.
Ashmead rejected the cancellation. He argued that the car was about 60 years old and had never been sold as being in showroom condition.
He said the car passed its roadworthy test on 26 May 2025 and was registered in Brand’s name that day. He also relied on the clause that excluded warranties.
Judge Mgengwana said a roadworthy certificate only confirms basic legal safety rules for public roads. It does not prove that every mechanical part works properly.
The court looked at WhatsApp messages between Brand and Knoep. In a message dated 30 May 2025, Knoep offered to send the car back to Central Garage to fix the air vent and a suspension leak.
The judge said these messages weakened Ashmead’s claim that Brand had made up his complaints.
Ashmead’s team also used a list of known faults, called a snag list, dated 6 December 2023. The judge said it was brought in too late, in a replying affidavit.
The judge said the list was made more than 10 months before Brand’s first inspection. It could not show the car’s condition in October 2024 or May 2025.
The list itself recorded a hydraulic fluid leak, a suspension control that did not work and a vent flap that would not close. The judge said these matched the faults Brand later reported.
The judge found that the no-warranties clause did not cancel Ashmead’s duty to deliver the car in its inspected condition. He ruled that Brand lawfully cancelled the sale on 29 May 2025 and does not have to pay the R3 million.
Source: this article is based on reporting by IOL. Image: IOL. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice News desk. See our Editorial Standards.
Kgomotso Maake covers news and politics for Tzaneen Voice. Kgomotso reports on government, Parliament, municipalities, courts, crime and service delivery across South Africa, with a close eye on how national decisions reach towns like Tzaneen and the wider Limpopo province. Stories are written in plain English and focus on the facts: who made the decision, what it means, and what happens next.