Court Orders Police Minister to Pay R2.43m to Man Assaulted in Krugersdorp Police Cell

By

November 18, 2026

The South Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg has ordered the Minister of Police to pay R2.43 million to a man assaulted by officers. Siyabulela Sompondo was beaten inside a holding cell at Krugersdorp Police Station in November 2014.

Judge Millar found the award was justified by the mix of physical and mental injuries Sompondo suffered. The assault left him with a hip injury, trauma and a reduced ability to work.

“Taken together the totality and combination of the plaintiff’s injuries are to my mind of sufficient severity to justify an award for general damages in the sum of R550 000.00,” the judge said.

The court had already found the minister liable in September 2019. It ruled then that officers had assaulted Sompondo while he was in custody. The latest hearing only decided how much he should be paid.

According to the earlier judgment, Sompondo was arrested on 3 November 2014 and held in a cell with six or seven other inmates. At around 6pm, three officers took him out of the cell.

Two officers locked him in an empty cell and demanded the names of his alleged partners in a robbery. They slapped him and hit him on the back with the cell keys.

When he fell, they kicked him and trampled on him. Sompondo testified that he lost consciousness. He said the officers also put a gun in his mouth and threatened to shoot him.

Medical experts for both sides agreed he needed crutches until October 2015. He was then sent to Charlotte Maxeke Hospital, where he had a hip replacement on 11 December 2016.

He recovered well but still has some pain and stiffness after long walks. The experts said the new hip would last 15 to 25 years and would need at least one more operation.

The surgeons linked half of his hip condition to the assault. They linked the other half to his history of heavy drinking.

The court heard that he still suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder and depression linked to the attack. Psychiatrists agreed he needs ongoing treatment.

Sompondo finished only Grade 9. At the time of the assault, he worked part time for a construction company, earning between R1,200 and R1,300 a month. He had also sold snacks and grilled chicken feet, earning about R1,000 a month.

Two industrial psychologists disagreed on whether he could ever work again. The judge took a figure midway between their calculations and applied a 65% deduction.

The award is made up of R900,859.50 for future medical costs, R981,155.07 for lost earnings and R550,000 in general damages. Sompondo had asked for R750,000 in general damages, while the minister argued for R300,000.

The minister must also pay interest from the date of judgment until payment. He must cover Sompondo’s legal costs, including the costs of his medical experts and actuary.

Source: this article is based on reporting by IOL. Image: IOL. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice News desk. See our Editorial Standards.