Pretoria High Court Orders WP Motors to Refund R267,607 for Ford Ranger Whose Engine Failed

By

November 19, 2026

The High Court in Pretoria has dismissed an appeal by car dealer WP Motors Sales. The dealer must now refund a buyer R267,607.49 for a used Ford Ranger whose engine failed two days after he bought it.

The court also upheld a R200,000 fine that the National Consumer Tribunal gave the dealer in March 2025. The tribunal found that WP Motors broke the Consumer Protection Act when it refused to cancel the sale.

“Section 56(2) gives the choice of remedy to the consumer, not to the supplier,” Judge Mmonoa Teffo said in the judgment. Acting judge Nelson Kekana agreed with her.

The buyer bought the 2015 Ford Ranger on 17 January 2020. Two days later, on its first long trip, the engine failed.

He told WP Motors in writing that he was returning the vehicle. The next day he asked for the sale to be cancelled.

According to the buyer, sales manager Mr de Bruin phoned him on 24 January 2020. He said the vehicle had overheated, possibly because of a broken pipe, and blamed the driver.

The dealer refused to cancel the sale and offered to repair the bakkie at its own cost. The buyer turned down the repair and asked for reports, which he did not get.

WP Motors rebuilt the engine anyway. The judge said the dealer itself put the cost of that work at more than R100,000.

The buyer then went to the Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa. On 22 April 2021, the ombudsman said no technical report showed the driver caused the breakdown. It recommended that the sale be cancelled within 15 working days.

The buyer complained to the National Consumer Commission in July 2021. WP Motors told the commission’s inspector it would refund him only if he paid for damages it said he owed. The commission sent the case to the tribunal on 31 October 2022.

Judge Teffo said a used vehicle whose engine fails two days after it was sold as roadworthy is not of good quality. She said it also fails the act’s test of being useable and durable for a reasonable time.

She said that when a supplier blames the consumer for a fault, it is up to the supplier to prove it. The only evidence for the dealer’s case was a letter and a note from the repairers. The tribunal had ruled these were hearsay and could not be used.

WP Motors argued that the buyer never clearly asked for a refund. The judge said this argument could not stand.

“A consumer who returns goods, cancels the transaction and says he wishes to avoid financial implications is directing the supplier to refund the price,” Teffo said.

She said repairing the vehicle after the buyer refused permission was itself a breach of the act. She called the later demand for damages “a demand for a penalty”, which she said the act “expressly forbids”.

The dealer also said the fine was too harsh because it had no past offences and acted without malice. The judge said the tribunal had weighed these points, as well as the dealer’s cooperation with the ombudsman and the commission.

Against that, the tribunal weighed that the buyer had lost both his vehicle and his money since January 2020. He has kept paying instalments in that time. The dealer also kept blaming him without ever producing a diagnostic report.

Teffo said fines under the act are meant to punish and to deter. She said a fine of one fifth of the legal maximum could not be called disproportionate. “I find no merit on this ground and it, therefore, fails,” she said.

The court also dismissed a cross appeal by the National Consumer Commission. The commission had asked for the fine to be raised to 10% of the dealer’s turnover or R1 million.

Source: this article is based on reporting by Moneyweb. Image: Moneyweb. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice Business desk. See our Editorial Standards.