KZN MEC Thulasizwe Buthelezi Wants to Appeal Ruling That Cancelled Three eThekwini Appointments

By

November 16, 2026

KwaZulu-Natal Cogta MEC Reverend Thulasizwe Buthelezi has asked for leave to appeal a court ruling that cancelled the appointments of three senior eThekwini managers.

In an application filed on November 13, Buthelezi is challenging the whole judgment of the Durban High Court. Judge Hlatshwayo handed down the ruling on November 10.

“The Court should have refused all of the relief sought by the Applicant, and dismissed the application with costs,” the application states in its final argument, according to IOL.

The Democratic Alliance brought the case. The party challenged the appointments of Lindokuhle Mkhize, Cyril Bhekinkosi Mkhize and Ednick Msweli.

The three were appointed as executive directors of Operations Management, Public Safety and Technical Services. The council approved them on November 13, 2025. Municipal manager Musa Mbhele made the appointments effective from November 15.

The DA raised concerns about how candidates were screened, their qualifications and how the council dealt with adverse Auditor-General findings involving Msweli.

The court also questioned a council resolution of December 4, 2025. It sought approval for yearly salaries of R2,916,751 for each of the three managers, less than a month after they were appointed.

Buthelezi said the judge did not properly recognise the MEC’s role in overseeing municipal appointments under the Municipal Systems Act. He said municipalities must send him screening reports, test results, interview minutes and council resolutions.

He said the ruling treated him like a “disinterested bystander”. The application calls the finding a “dangerous precedent and legally incorrect” that could “clip the wings of COGTA”.

He also said the court made findings about his department even though no order was sought against Cogta.

On the Auditor-General findings, Buthelezi said the question was whether the council had considered them. He said the municipality showed they were discussed at both the executive committee and full council meetings.

He rejected the court’s view that the council used a majority vote to “bypass accountability”. He said the council followed a “deliberative, plenary council process”.

Buthelezi said the council was allowed to rely on the municipal manager’s report on the candidates’ qualifications and experience. He said missing reference checks were done before the selection committee made its final picks. He called the court’s approach “unduly formalistic”.

He also disputed the finding that the appointments were a “foregone conclusion” made in bad faith. He said Mbhele gave reasons for the November 15 start date, including avoiding a leadership gap when acting appointments ended.

The MEC is also challenging the order to cancel the appointments with immediate effect. He said the court did not consider the harm to the three managers or to service delivery in the city.

He further objected to the court’s declaration that councillors did not break the Code of Conduct by sharing closed council talks for the court case. He said this creates a “blanket, retrospective judicial exemption” from confidentiality rules.

Buthelezi wants the Supreme Court of Appeal to hear the appeal against the entire judgment and order.

Source: this article is based on reporting by IOL. Image: IOL. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice News desk. See our Editorial Standards.