Appeal Court Rejects Durban Man’s R5.4 Million Claim Against Police Over 2002 Arrest

By

November 17, 2026

The Supreme Court of Appeal has turned down a Nigerian man’s bid to revive his R5.4 million unlawful arrest claim against the Minister of Police. He was arrested for murder in 2002 after a man was found hanging in a Durban room he had rented.

Sunday Ikechukwu Okoro was arrested without a warrant on 3 July 2002. Police had found a man’s body hanging from a bedsheet in the shower of room 7 at Evaleigh Court, according to IOL.

Okoro had rented the room two days earlier. He stayed in custody until 29 November 2002, when the charges against him were withdrawn.

He later sued the Minister of Police for R5.41 million. He said his arrest and detention were unlawful and caused him loss and suffering.

The KwaZulu-Natal High Court in Durban dismissed his claim with costs. It found that police had reasonable grounds to suspect him of murder.

Okoro was refused leave to appeal by both the High Court and the SCA. He then asked the President of the appeal court to reconsider that refusal.

A panel of three judges heard the matter. Two of them, Molitsoane and Nicholls, ruled against him, and his application was struck off the roll with costs.

The court heard that Warrant Officers Allen Mark Naidu and Sunil Seosunker were on crime prevention duty in Durban’s Point area. They saw Okoro outside Evaleigh Court.

Naidu said Okoro went into the building after seeing their police vehicle, so the officers followed him. Naidu later saw Okoro come out of room 7 upset and shouting the name Francine.

Okoro asked the officers to follow him into the room. There they found the man hanging in the shower. His body was cold and stiff, with no pulse.

Naidu said he suspected the hanging had been staged to hide a murder. He told the court the man’s feet were not close enough to the shower ledge, and the knot also raised questions.

The court heard Okoro had given the two sets of keys to two other people, named as Amanda and Aubrey. He could not tell police where they were.

The majority said the facts around the body, Okoro’s link to the room and the officer’s observations gave reasonable grounds for suspicion. It said police do not need proof beyond reasonable doubt before making an arrest.

The court also rejected the argument that police should have collected expert and forensic evidence before arresting him.

On his detention after his first court appearance on 8 July 2002, the court looked at what the prosecution had. This included statements from police, a security guard and two post-mortem reports.

Security guard Milton Dlungele said he saw Okoro enter and leave the room three times on the day the body was found.

State pathologist Dr Kirk found the death was consistent with suicide, but he could not fully rule out murder. Dr Perumal, hired by the dead man’s family, believed it was likely a killing.

The majority found no evidence that police misled the prosecution or hid information to keep Okoro in jail. It said the prosecutor made her own decision to take the case to court.

Judge Mjali disagreed with the majority. He found Okoro was not the only person with access to the room and police made no serious effort to find the others with keys.

Mjali said Okoro had led officers to the body and appeared shocked. He would have held the minister liable for Okoro’s proven damages.

Molitsoane raised concern about how long the case took. The summons was reportedly issued around October 2003, but the trial only started on 19 October 2020.

He called the delay inordinate and unacceptable. He said it hurt public trust in the justice system and the right to a hearing within a reasonable time.

Source: this article is based on reporting by IOL. Image: IOL. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice News desk. See our Editorial Standards.