The Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) could face a fine of about R340 million if it loses a competition case brought after a complaint by rival exchange A2X Markets.
The estimate comes from Donald MacKay, CEO of XA Global Trade Advisors. He told BizNews the amount would be about 10% of the JSE’s yearly income and roughly a third of its net profit.
“Should the JSE lose at the tribunal, it will force a fundamental change in how stock exchanges operate in South Africa,” MacKay said.
The JSE has denied the claims. It said it has cooperated fully with the Competition Commission. It also said external lawyers advised it that the commission’s claims have no merit.
A2X Markets lodged its complaint with the Competition Commission in October 2022. It claimed the JSE abused its dominant position in the market to keep competitors out.
The complaint focused on two parts of the JSE’s business. These are its broker-dealer accounting (BDA) system and its matched principal (MP) trade type.
After a three-year investigation, the commission referred the case to the Competition Tribunal in October 2025. It asked the tribunal to prosecute the JSE and to order changes to its rules on the BDA system and MP trades. It also asked for a possible fine.
MacKay said the bigger effect would be the changes the JSE might have to make to how it does business. He said this could make it easier for other exchanges to compete.
“You can’t buy your way out of that by paying a fine. You have to stop the anti-competitive behaviour that started all of this in the first place,” he said.
A2X welcomed the commission’s decision to refer the case. It said South Africa’s share market had been run by one main player for more than a century.
A2X CEO Kevin Brady said this market structure had led to fewer listings, flat trading levels and higher costs for companies and investors. A2X also said markets in Europe, Australia and India had gained from more competition between exchanges.
MacKay also raised concerns about how long the case has taken. By October 2026, the matter had been waiting for a tribunal decision for about a year. He warned that delays in competition cases can let the alleged conduct carry on.
He questioned how the JSE has explained the risk to its investors. The exchange told investors about the case but said it did not see a high chance of losing. MacKay said clearer information would help investors understand the possible cost.
He did not say the JSE had to record the fine as a liability in its financial statements. He said only that more disclosure would help.
MacKay said several other exchanges in South Africa had failed, while some were close to shutting down. He said he could not link their problems directly to the JSE’s alleged conduct.
The JSE is both a player in the market and a body that regulates parts of that market. It was South Africa’s only stock exchange for around 100 years.
It is still not clear what orders the tribunal could give if it rules against the exchange. The Competition Tribunal has not yet made a final decision.
Source: this article is based on reporting by Daily Investor. Image: Daily Investor. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice Business desk. See our Editorial Standards.
Anelisa Nkuna covers business and money news for Tzaneen Voice. Anelisa reports on the rand, fuel prices, interest rates, jobs, Eskom, Transnet, farming and company results. The aim is simple: explain what the numbers mean for household budgets, small businesses and workers in South Africa.