Nick Mallett Says Late Front-Row Change Hurt Springboks in 21-19 Loss to France

By

November 17, 2026

Former Springbok coach Nick Mallett said a late change to the starting front-row played a part in South Africa’s 21-19 defeat to France on Friday.

Coach Rassie Erasmus first named Malcolm Marx, Ox Nche and Wilco Louw to start. One hour before kick-off at the Stade de France, he moved all three to the bench.

Jan-Hendrik Wessels, Gerhard Steenekamp and Thomas du Toit, who had been named as cover, started the Nations Championship Test instead.

“I was a bit concerned by seeing the change of the front-row so late,” Mallett told the Talking Boks podcast, according to Planet Rugby.

Mallett said the Springboks usually win through scrum power, strength in the air, direct ball carrying, physical defence and kicking for territory.

He said picking a more athletic front-row looked like an attempt to copy France’s fast style of play. “But for me, it didn’t work because we didn’t get any scrum dominance and we started playing like France,” he said.

France led 14-0 early and went into half-time 21-7 ahead. Mallett said the Boks did not kick for territory in the first 10 minutes.

“We were running from well within our own 10-metre line,” he said. He added that players were often tackled behind the advantage line and the team gave away turnovers.

He said the game opened with a turnover and a penalty. France scrumhalf Maxime Lucu then missed his kick for the corner, so the start could have been even worse.

Marx, Nche and Louw came on about five minutes before half-time. Mallett said they steadied the side, and France did not score a point in the second half.

Mallett said he believed Erasmus was worried about France’s speed in the opening 10 to 15 minutes. He said Louw is an outstanding scrummager but lacks pace and sideways movement.

“I personally would always start with the best tighthead scrummager to impose our game on them,” Mallett said. He called Nche the best loosehead in the world and Marx the best hooker in the world.

He said he would keep the heavier front-row on for 60 minutes in a tight game. The quicker players could then come on for the last 20 minutes.

“I think he wanted to match mobility with mobility, put it that way. But unfortunately, it didn’t work,” Mallett said.

He said the Springboks did fight back, but their attack was not accurate enough to win.

The loss in Paris was the Springboks’ second defeat in a row. They lost narrowly to Australia in Perth in September.

Source: this article is based on reporting by Planet Rugby. Image: Planet Rugby. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice Sports desk. See our Editorial Standards.