Teachers at a poor Western Cape school said their principal gave them no real support to grow their skills, a new study found.
The researchers compared two public secondary schools in the Western Cape Metropole Central Education District. One was a quintile 1 school, which serves the poorest communities. The other was a quintile 5 school, which serves the wealthiest communities.
“There is a measure of support from principals in the teaching and learning aspect of the teachers’ work. But it’s limited at the quintile 1 (under-resourced) school, where it is most needed,” the researchers wrote in The Conversation.
The study looked at continuous professional teacher development, known as CPTD. South African teachers must take part in these activities to keep their skills up to date.
The activities include personal study, school workshops, mentorship circles and courses run by outside providers. Most are approved by the South African Council for Educators, and teachers earn points for finishing them.
The team interviewed six teachers from the two schools. Each teacher had more than three years of classroom experience. The researchers said small groups are common in this kind of study because they allow deeper talks.
Teachers at the quintile 1 school said support from their principal was non-existent. They said Western Cape Education Department workshops felt more like a tick-box exercise than real learning.
These teachers also said they had no faith in their principal or heads of department to guide their development. They said they got no help with classroom management or with handling disruptive learners.
At the quintile 5 school, the picture was different. Teachers said all learners and parents had to agree to a code of conduct, and learners who broke it faced consequences.
The researchers said the principal there helped indirectly. The principal encouraged senior staff to arrange subject training and made time for teachers to attend. Subject advisers and departmental heads led these sessions.
The study found no proof that principals at either school had a direct effect on how teachers know and teach their subjects.
Teachers at both schools said ongoing learning mattered in their job. “The learners of five years ago are not the same learners that we are teaching now,” one teacher told the researchers.
One teacher close to retirement said training was most important for new teachers. It helps them with lesson planning, preparation and running a classroom, the teacher said.
The researchers said many teachers see the training as an extra burden. They already face overcrowded classes, poor discipline and heavy teaching and admin workloads.
The researchers said training does not work when it is only about following rules. They said it should respond to what teachers actually need.
They called on principals to find out what teachers need to learn and to involve teachers in training decisions. They also asked principals to work more closely with departmental heads and subject advisers.
Source: this article is based on reporting by The Conversation. Image: The Conversation. Written with the help of AI and published by the Tzaneen Voice News desk. See our Editorial Standards.
Kgomotso Maake covers news and politics for Tzaneen Voice. Kgomotso reports on government, Parliament, municipalities, courts, crime and service delivery across South Africa, with a close eye on how national decisions reach towns like Tzaneen and the wider Limpopo province. Stories are written in plain English and focus on the facts: who made the decision, what it means, and what happens next.